https://svn.lrde.epita.fr/svn/oln/trunk/milena Closes https://trac.lrde.org/olena/ticket/135. Index: ChangeLog from Roland Levillain &lt;roland(a)lrde.epita.fr&gt; Have mln::util::vertex_id and mln::util::edge_id be distinct types. * mln/util/internal/graph_base.hh (mln::util::gen_id<Tag, Typename>): New class. (mln::util::vertex_tag, mln::util::edge_tag): New tags (mln::util::vertex_id, mln::util::edge_id): Define these typedefs as specializations of mln::util::gen_id instead of unsigned. (mln::util::graph_base<V, E>::add_edge_): Adjust. (operator==(const edge<E>&, const edge<E>&)) (operator< (const edge<E>&, const edge<E>&)): Add missing an inline qualifier. (mln::util::graph_base<V, E>::vertex(vertex_id)): Have the declarations and definitions of thee methods have the exact same signature. * mln/core/line_graph_psite.hh (line_graph_psite(const p_line_graph<P>&, util::edge_id)) (mln::util::line_graph_psite<P>::id): Likewise. * mln/core/graph_psite.hh (graph_psite(const p_graph<P>&, util::vertex_id)): Likewise. * mln/core/p_line_graph_piter.hh (p_line_graph_fwd_piter_<P>::next_): (p_line_graph_bkd_piter_<P>::next_): Adjust. * tests/morpho/lena_line_graph_image_wst1.cc: Adjust. mln/core/graph_psite.hh | 2 mln/core/line_graph_psite.hh | 4 mln/core/p_line_graph_piter.hh | 4 mln/util/internal/graph_base.hh | 160 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++--- tests/morpho/lena_line_graph_image_wst1.cc | 2 5 files changed, 153 insertions(+), 19 deletions(-) Index: tests/morpho/lena_line_graph_image_wst1.cc --- tests/morpho/lena_line_graph_image_wst1.cc (revision 2002) +++ tests/morpho/lena_line_graph_image_wst1.cc (working copy) @@ -126,7 +126,7 @@ is bad. util:graph<N,E>::add_vertex should return this id. */ points[p] = id; - ++id; + ++id.to_equiv(); } // Edges. Index: mln/core/line_graph_psite.hh --- mln/core/line_graph_psite.hh (revision 2002) +++ mln/core/line_graph_psite.hh (working copy) @@ -61,7 +61,7 @@ /// Construction and assignment. /// \{ line_graph_psite(); - line_graph_psite(const p_line_graph<P>& plg, unsigned id); + line_graph_psite(const p_line_graph<P>& plg, util::edge_id id); line_graph_psite(const self_& rhs); self_& operator= (const self_& rhs); /// \} @@ -224,7 +224,7 @@ template<typename P> inline - util::vertex_id + util::edge_id line_graph_psite<P>::id() const { return id_; Index: mln/core/p_line_graph_piter.hh --- mln/core/p_line_graph_piter.hh (revision 2002) +++ mln/core/p_line_graph_piter.hh (working copy) @@ -281,7 +281,7 @@ void p_line_graph_fwd_piter_<P>::next_() { - ++id_; + ++id_.to_equiv(); if (is_valid()) update_(); } @@ -422,7 +422,7 @@ void p_line_graph_bkd_piter_<P>::next_() { - --id_; + --id_.to_equiv(); if (is_valid()) update_(); } Index: mln/core/graph_psite.hh --- mln/core/graph_psite.hh (revision 2002) +++ mln/core/graph_psite.hh (working copy) @@ -58,7 +58,7 @@ /// Construction and assignment. /// \{ graph_psite(); - graph_psite(const p_graph<P>& pg_, unsigned id); + graph_psite(const p_graph<P>& pg_, util::vertex_id id); graph_psite(const self_& rhs); self_& operator= (const self_& rhs); /// \} Index: mln/util/internal/graph_base.hh --- mln/util/internal/graph_base.hh (revision 2002) +++ mln/util/internal/graph_base.hh (working copy) @@ -40,35 +40,79 @@ # include <ostream> # include <mln/core/concept/object.hh> + # include <mln/util/ordpair.hh> +# include <mln/value/builtin/integers.hh> namespace mln { namespace util { - /* FIXME: We should create actual types for vertex_id and edge_id, - (not just typedefs), at least to prevent the user from using a - vertex_id where an edge_id is expected (and vice versa). - Conversion to and from unsigned would still be useful, but it - might be safer to turn them into explicit ones. + /*--------------. + | Identifiers. | + `--------------*/ - See what the Vaucanson team did for the handles of - vertices/states in their graphs/automata implemenations here: + /// \brief Generic identifier/handler. + /// + /// Inspired by Vaucansons's handlers for automata. + /// + /// https://svn.lrde.epita.fr/svn/vaucanson/trunk/include/vaucanson/automata/co… + /// https://svn.lrde.epita.fr/svn/vaucanson/trunk/include/vaucanson/automata/co… + // + // \todo We /might/ want to integrate this into Milena's value system. + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + class gen_id + { + typedef gen_id<Tag, Equiv> self_t; - https://trac.lrde.org/vaucanson/browser/trunk/include/vaucanson/automata/co… + public: + typedef Equiv equiv; + + gen_id(); + gen_id(const Equiv& e); + self_t& operator=(const Equiv& e); + + const equiv& to_equiv() const; + equiv& to_equiv(); + operator const equiv() const; + operator equiv(); + + private: + equiv e_; + }; + + /// Compare two identifiers. + /// \{ + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + bool + operator==(const gen_id<Tag, Equiv>& i, const gen_id<Tag, Equiv>& j); + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + bool + operator==(const Equiv& i, const gen_id<Tag, Equiv>& j); + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + bool + operator==(const gen_id<Tag, Equiv>& i, const Equiv j); + /// \} - We /might/ want to integrate this into Milena's value system. */ + /// Tags. + /// \{ + struct vertex_tag; + struct edge_tag; + /// \} /// \brief The type used to identify vertices. /// /// Used internally as a key to manipulate vertices. - typedef unsigned vertex_id; + typedef gen_id<vertex_tag, unsigned> vertex_id; /// \brief The type used to identify edges. /// /// Used internally as a key to manipulate edges. - typedef unsigned edge_id; + typedef gen_id<edge_tag, unsigned> edge_id; /*---------. @@ -180,7 +224,7 @@ /// Return the vertex whose id is \a v. /// \{ util::vertex<V>& vertex(vertex_id v); - const util::vertex<V>& vertex(edge_id v) const; + const util::vertex<V>& vertex(vertex_id v) const; /// \} /// Return the edge whose id is \a e. @@ -242,7 +286,93 @@ # ifndef MLN_INCLUDE_ONLY + /*--------------. + | Identifiers. | + `--------------*/ + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + inline + gen_id<Tag, Equiv>::gen_id() + { + } + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + inline + gen_id<Tag, Equiv>::gen_id(const Equiv& e) + : e_ (e) + { + } + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + inline + gen_id<Tag, Equiv>& + gen_id<Tag, Equiv>::operator=(const Equiv& e) + { + e_ = e; + return *this; + } + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + inline + const Equiv& + gen_id<Tag, Equiv>::to_equiv() const + { + return e_; + } + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + inline + Equiv& + gen_id<Tag, Equiv>::to_equiv() + { + return e_; + } + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + inline + gen_id<Tag, Equiv>::operator const Equiv() const + { + return to_equiv(); + } + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + inline + gen_id<Tag, Equiv>::operator Equiv() + { + return to_equiv(); + } + + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + inline + bool + operator==(const gen_id<Tag, Equiv>& i, const gen_id<Tag, Equiv>& j) + { + return i.to_equiv() == j.to_equiv(); + } + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + inline + bool + operator==(const Equiv& i, const gen_id<Tag, Equiv>& j) + { + return i == j.to_equiv(); + } + + template <typename Tag, typename Equiv> + inline + bool + operator==(const gen_id<Tag, Equiv>& i, const Equiv j) + { + return i.to_equiv() == j; + } + + /*---------------------. + | Operators on edges. | + `---------------------*/ + template <typename E> + inline bool operator==(const edge<E>& lhs, const edge<E>& rhs) { @@ -250,6 +380,7 @@ } template <typename E> + inline bool operator< (const edge<E>& lhs, const edge<E>& rhs) { @@ -447,7 +578,10 @@ delete edge; edge = 0; // Return the erroneous value. - return mln_max(edge_id); + /* FIXME: We have to explicitly extract the numerical + equivalent type here, because mln::util::gen_id<T, E> + is not compatible with Milena's value system (yet). */ + return mln_max(edge_id::equiv); } else {